| | | | | | | |

Karens Bakery Danish Puff Pastries Review

A hand holding a whole Danish Puff Pastry cookie from Karens Bakery.

Author’s note: I have no affiliation with Karens Bakery or Costco, and this is not a sponsored review.

The good kind of Karen.

This is the kind of Karen I want to be friends with.

A hand holding a box of Karens Bakery Danish Puff Pastries Lemon Flavor Cookies from Costco.

These “Danish Puff Pastries” are basically a fancy sandwich cookie with lemon creme filling inside. But they aren’t like any cookie I’ve ever had before. What makes them special is that the wafers are kind of a cross between a cracker and a croissant.

A very flat croissant? A crackssant? They’re crisper than a typical baked pastry: airy, flakey, and delicate. The oblong shape reminds me of a nutter butter, but in a classier zip code.

Textured sugar crust on the outside of a Karens Bakery Danish Puff Pastry Cookie from Costco.

Caramelized sugar crust

I like the contrast of the crunchy, sugar-crusted top. The sugar is sort of caramelized and melted onto the surface, which gives extra flavor. Kind of a creme brulee vibe. There’s a surprise sprinkle of salt, too, which I loved. Salt enhances the demure flavors. I think salt belongs everywhere.

Fingers holding a bitten Karens Bakery Danish Puff Pastry Cookie, showing the lemon creme filling.

Lemon creme filling

The lemon filling is much richer than I expected. It’s not thick, per se. Just creamy/fatty. Less sugar, more fat. This is exactly what I prefer. I also like that the icing is only in the center of the wafer, so that it doesn’t taste like too much when you’re eating these.

I would describe it as moderately sweet. When combined with the puff pastry wafers, it evens out to a “lightly sweet” effect. If you have a raging sweet tooth, you might hate this. But I loved it.

(For another sandwich cookie with a lightly sweet creme center, you might enjoy my review of these petite spiced cookies from Aldi, which are imported from Germany.)

An open Danish Puff Pastry Cooke from Karens Bakery, showing the lemon creme filling.

Lemon flavor

The filling has a whisper-light lemon taste. I think you could feed this to a lemon-hater, and they wouldn’t even be mad. It’s not tart or zingy. It’s like the distant memory of a lemon. A super mellow hint of citrus is all you’re getting. A lemon kiss.

There’s not much flavor outside of that. I don’t mind that, because it doesn’t drown out the delicate pastry flavors.

(If you love desserts with gentle lemon flavor, check out my review of Costco’s Lemon Custard Pie.)

Fingers holding a side view of a Lemon flavor Danish Puff Pastry Cookie from Karens Bakery.

Serving the cookies

The novelty of these cookies makes them ideal for an elegant tea party or buffet spread. Something out of the ordinary, and special. Your food snobs will be intrigued. Even the Karens. Probably.

Four sealed trays of Karens Bakery Danish Puff Pastries from Costco sitting on a kitchen table.

I LOVED that my cookies were sealed in FOUR separate packets. This allows me to keep the uneaten ones fresh much longer. I live in Florida, where the humidity destroys crispy foods faster than mosquitoes multiply.

Ingredients in Karens Bakery Danish Puff Pastries

Ingredients in Karens Bakery Lemon Puff Pastry Danish Cookies.

Here is my best attempt at typing out the ingredients from the label:

  • Wheat Flour
  • Vegetable Oils (Palm, Canola)
  • Sugar
  • Salt
  • Natural Lemon Flavor
  • Protease (dough conditioner)

It’s amazing how these few, simple ingredients create such an unexpected flavor and texture experience. This is how it should be. We don’t need a zillion ingredients. Do we?

More information from the label:

  • Product of Denmark
  • Since 1890
  • By appointment to the Royal Danish Court [*raises pinky*]

Nutrition Facts

Nutrition Facts in Danish Puff Pastry Lemon Cookies from Karens Bakery.

A serving is two cookies and contains 150 calories. You get 10 grams of fat (4.5 grams saturated fat) and less than 1 gram of protein. There are 15 grams total carbohydrates, of which 8 grams are sugar (all of them are “added sugar”) and 0 grams are fiber. You get just 3% your daily value of sodium and 0% your daily value cholesterol.

Price and Servings

The 22.5 ounce package cost $9.99 at my local Costco. Since there are 24 servings per package, each serving costs 42 cents at the regular price.

Shelf Life

The “best by” date on my package allowed approximately 8 months to consume.

Dramatic Conclusion

A hand-drawn-diagram of an "Awesome-o-Meter," measuring from "Never Again" to "Speechless." The arrow is pointing to "Yaaas."

If you’re a fan of crisp, airy, lightly sweet treats, these Karens Bakery Danish Puff Pastries might be for you. This is a unique treat that is unlike anything I’ve had before.

The trusty Awesome-o-Meter rates these unique cookies a solid “Yaaas.” I’d love to try more flavors. Can we get a variety pack? Can we?! Please, mother!

The End.


More Reviews You Might Like (or Hate)

Check out these other reviews I’ve written. Or don’t. Free will!